A few weeks ago, I composed a post about the possibilities of using the NoodleBib shared assignment dropbox feature as a formative assessment for evaluating working bibliographies and notecards. Now that I’ve completed two research project “checkpoints” using the shared assignment dropbox, I am happy to share that this formative assessment has been successful in:
1. Gaining insight into the selection of information sources by students and to help them identify gaps in sources they may be overlooking that could inform their research.
2. Helping students identify and understand the mistakes they’ve made in the citation process and working with them to correct the entries.
3. Seeing what students are doing really well with their notetaking skills and providing positive feedback while identifying areas of weakness and then engaging in a conversation for learning with the student by sharing strategies for tackling those “challenge” areas with notetaking skills.
My roles in facilitating these formative assessments included:
1. Setting up the shared assignment dropboxes.
2. Teaching students how to share an assignment and confirming I had received the assignments from each group.
3. Taking the time to evaluate each group’s bibliographic entries and notecards while providing feedback.
4. Keeping a spreadsheet of general notes for each group’s work and noting patterns in what students were doing well and common problems I saw in student work.
5. Sharing my findings and notes with my co-teacher, Susan Lester, and then the two of us working together with groups to address challenges I identified through the formative assessment; in addition, I enlisted the assistance of students who were demonstrating specific skills in an exemplary manner to help peers on an “as needed” basis.
I love how easy it is to evaluate bibliographic individual entries and the accompanying notecards for each source cited in one screen. All you have to do is log into your account, scroll down to the bottom of your project lists page, and then open a student project (which for these assignments, were collaboratively created lists for group research projects). You can then click on “Bibliography” to access the bibliographic entries and accompanying notecards on one screen; you can then enter custom comments for each entry, and for the notecards, you can compose custom comments or use a comment from the pre-existing database of notecard comments. You can see when each entry and notecard were created as well as time/date of any revisions a student may have made. Take a look at how easy it is to work with the interface in the screenshots below (please note student names have been removed to protect their privacy).
Figure 1: Bibliographic Entry Comments
Figure 2: Comments on Electronic Notecards
I absolutely love using the shared assignment dropbox for formative assessment of student work and using the feedback with students to initiate or sustain conversations for learning. Here are a few features I’d suggest to make the shared assignment dropbox in NoodleBib even better:
- add the ability to message a group or comment on overall project
- add the ability for teachers and librarians to create their own banks of custom comments to both the notecards as well as bibliographic entries
- add a spellchecker on the teacher/librarian side to spellcheck comments
- add the ability for the librarian or teacher to “like” a student bibliographic entry or notecard (a la Facebook style)
- add the ability to create threaded discussions Facebook or new Google Docs discussions style so that students and the teacher and/or librarian can engage in a virtual discussion about the feedback provided (think ramped-up commenting!)
If you haven’t tried the shared dropbox in NoodleBib, I encourage you to give it a try as a way to embed yourself in the classroom with teachers and students as part of your collaborative partnerships and to participate meaningfully in assessment of student work. If you have tried the shared assignment dropbox as formative assessment, what features did you like, or what enhancements would you like to see added for 2011-12?